1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Dining in St. Thomas
  4.  » Bluebeard’s Castle — A Treasure Trove Of New Eateries

Coconut Post

VI News ’n Views



Bluebeard’s Castle — A Treasure Trove Of New Eateries

Written by Coconut Post

Whether you’re in St. Thomas, Virgin Islands as a visitor, a local — or always in spirit — Coconut Post keeps you posted on fun-filled news ’n views. Published monthly by Flamboyan On The Bay Resort & Villas, we’re focused on sharing our people, places, and fun things happening in paradise.

December, 2021

Named for the legendary pirate, historic Bluebeard’s Castle has been a hub of activity on St. Thomas since the 1600s. Strategically located, the hilltop complex offers breathtaking panoramas of the harbor, cruise ship dock and downtown Charlotte Amalie. 

Today, in addition to going back in time at the on-premise museum inside Bluebeard’s Tower, residents and visitors have the opportunity to wine and dine at several new restaurants. What a “best of all worlds” experience!

After hurricanes Irma and Maria decimated the island in 2017, the Bluebeard’s hotel operation went into rebuild mode. Meanwhile, business partners Jeff Lemen, Jason Slocum and Adrain Hale — of Greengos Caribbean Cantina and Smoking Rooster fame — took over all storm-ravaged restaurant properties including Banana Tree, Cabana Bar, and Room With A View. The visionary trio set to work redesigning each restaurant facility at Bluebeard’s with a fresh outlook. 

The result? Sunnyside Cafe and Pool Bar features daily brunch, lunch, light evening fare and Happy Hour delights. Check out tasty pizza options; try a locally brewed craft beer. Signature cocktails include the Castle Mai Tai made with Cruzan mango rum. Or how about a refreshing Da Greengo Cucumber Margarita? Frozen concoction choices range from the classic Creamsicle to Root Beer Float, Choc-Covered Strawberry, and Pistachio Grasshopper. 

Above: Daily brunch entrees at Sunnyside Cafe include the Country Skillet featuring eggs, ham, bacon peppers, onions and green chili salsa with choice of a side dish.  

Top of the page: Restaurant manager Janee Tune and executive chef Earl Elrod pose by a fascinating undersea mural at Bluebeard’s Castle. 

Above: Executive chef Earl Elrod brings a wealth of talent to the gastronomic scene at Bluebeard’s Castle. 

Above: Aptly named, Sunnyside Cafe on the pool deck at Bluebeard’s Castle offers a spectacular view, tasty food, and friendly atmosphere.

Deck With A View offers evening meals with creative salads and luscious appetizers such as mussels prepared with Spanish chorizo, FTB Rooster Brown Ale, and served with warm ciabatta loaf. In addition to fresh catch specials, entree choices include oven-roasted chicken, porterhouse grilled pork chop, grass-fed New York strip, pan-seared shrimp ’n scallops, or fresh pasta.

Keep in mind, The Castle Coffee & Deli is a convenient spot to enjoy beverages and deli items. Seating is available in the adjacent outside courtyard. 

The arrival of 2022 means The Castle Gastropub will be up and running — offering chef-inspired pub fare. 

When it comes to inspired chefs, Bluebeard’s hit the jackpot. The culinary talent at the helm of this appealing complex of gastronomic eateries is Executive Chef Earl Elrod.

Originally from Indiana, Chef Earl’s introduction to island life began in 2004 with an invitation to work at the iconic Craig and Sally’s restaurant in Frenchtown. “I came to St. Thomas on a one-way ticket to take the job,” he recalled.

The restaurant closed in 2012 but Elrod retained his formidable presence in Frenchtown as a chef and entrepreneur at Pie Whole before transitioning to Smoking Rooster in Havensight — and on to Bluebeard’s.

The newest addition to the Bluebeard’s restaurant team is manager Janee Tune.

Formerly an executive chef at Bolongo Bay Beach Resort, her culinary studies brought her to Provence in France and the Piedmont region of Italy, as well as New Orleans and the Caribbean.

Commented Chef Elrod, “Janee really knows her way around the kitchen and that’s invaluable.”

For more information, follow them on Facebook, email SunnysideCafeVI@gmail.com or call 340-643-8366. 

By the way, Frenchtown Brewing Company soon will be expanding with a second location at Bluebeard’s Castle.


You May Also Like…

Spotlighting Legendary St. Thomas Artist Camille Pissarro (1830 – 1903)

Spotlighting Legendary St. Thomas Artist Camille Pissarro (1830 – 1903)

Known as the “Father of Impressionism,” Jacob Abraham Camille Pissarro was a Danish-French Impressionist and Neo-Impressionist painter born on the island of St. Thomas in 1830 when it was part of the Danish West Indies. Art historian John Rewald called Pissarro the “dean of the Impressionist painters.” Pissarro was also one of Paul Gauguin’s masters.

read more
Visit Smith Bay Beach — A Hidden Gem On The East End

Visit Smith Bay Beach — A Hidden Gem On The East End

Smith Bay Beach — a 21-acre park located just off Route 38 —is home to an intriguing assortment of plants, birds and marine life. For decades, the sleepy area just off the beaten path on the road to Red Hook was known to locals as Lindquist. Over time, the isolated shoreline became ever-more popular with local groups keeping it clean and inviting.

read more


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *